Firstly I'll say that I've only played the PS2 version of Angel of Darkness so far, although once the PC version goes budget I'll get that too
Five good things about the game
1) Its actually done something different for a change.
2) Large, beautiful, varied locations
3) The graphics and general atmosphere are far improved.
4) More emphasis on plot and character development
5) It feels as if the series has finally evolved spiritually as well as asthetically
Five bad things about the game:
1) Very buggy. My PS2 crashed numerous times
2) Loading times are too long and too frequent - in the middle of a level? Grr
3) Character interaction feels flimsy, doesn't really add much to the game or change the plot dramatically
4) Lara sometimes looks like a fish out of water - where's the Tombs man?
5) They made her boobs smaller
The first three bad points don't means its a bad game, they mean its a rushed game
Personally I think the whole Eidos taking Lara away from Core thing is majorly f**ked up - Core invented the character and game in the first place as far as I am aware. Taking TombRaider away from Core means taking at least 80% of their company's float value, and thats going to be hard to recover from.
That said, I used to get real mad at Core for simply riding the Lara cash cow and spewing out identikit games. Although they have re-adressed the balance somewhat with this last game, I can certainly understand why the brand as a whole has dwindled in popularity. Plus the last game was victim to SERIOUS over hyping.
I like the new game, it kept me interested plot-wise, the levels were expansive, varied and interesting, and the new control system, although initially hard to get used to allows for more realistic levels and precise skill in controlling the game. Probably felt the freshest game since the first, which is a very good thing
...but personally I think for a major release to have so many bugs as this on CONSOLE (and therefore non-patchable) format is unnacceptable. You have to save every few minutes in case you need to Reset away from a BSOD lol
Oh and the whole second movie being a flop thing, I would hazzard a guess that wasn't down to the game, more down to the fact it was a generic and ultimately samey sequel to an ok film with a weak plotline and overused staple token Hollywood pre-set effects. No where near dark or edgy enough. And anyway, the only reason most people went to see the first movie was to see Angelina Jolie in the suit - and they've already seen that, over and over on their slow-mo replays on DVD
Quikly Studio Pro. Soon. Honest.