I do DJ at events, clubs and what have you I wear that term proudly as it's been a little warped over the years as now all I see is this
Modern DJ: Pressing play on MacBook
What I do and consider a real DJ: Scratching, beat matching, overlaying, live remixing, etc. Actual study of the art of turntablism, origins of old school music and development of turntablism such as deep house, jungle and hip-hop. And of coarse, getting the crowd going and keeping the energy flowing.
Still, I in no way said they your stuff is bad, I feel like you jumped to a weird conclusion from my statement. It's not my typical style, but that doesn't mean it's bad, you put a lot effort into it, and it abides by a genre, in fact, what do you define as a "good" or "bad" song? Seems a little odd, by basic logical a "bad" song could be just one that a person doesn't find desirable or is musically incorrect (off beat, off key, badly recorded, etc.), it's pretty much all what you make of it.
That being said, the poster here made his first dubstep, it's in no way bad. It is his first song, and I admit, my first songs were awful (trust me your doing A LOT better then I was my first time Slayer).
Quote: "If you are going to give someone feedback on something they have done for the first time (Slayer267's tune) Then at least be civil. Point out what could do with being changed, but, explain to him how he could change it. Simply saying,
Quote: "1. Dump the weird 90's happy hardcore kick in the start"
doesn't help him. Explain to him your thoughts and any method you might use instead of the "weird 90's happy hardcore kick ".
Unfamillia"
While it was a bit deragatory, there was reasoning behind it. I figured that most new producers (like I was and you were at one time) don't know all of the termaloigy. Still it was a bit out there and I appologize, but when it comes to new producers, I figure it's best to be as specific as possible about things.
I could have said:
Use a deeper kick drum, add some compression, maybe a bit of distortion later in an automation clip, you could use a simple sample or a drum machine.
versus
try and remove the kick at the begging and explore some other ones, it's a bit to crunchy and doesn't quite fit with the song. Try looking for some samples online like here: [a link to help them].
Sorry if I have offended you unfamillia

I am not a fan of MLP
, but that's just me