Benchmarking AGK Sprite Draws - GameCreators Forum

Author

Message

Grizzlius_Maximus

7

Years of Service

User Offline

Joined: 16th Oct 2017

Location:

Posted: 30th Apr 2020 07:04

Link

I want to remake this game (from gms 1.4) using AGK. The game allows you to spawn infinite amount of bears (It's called Beartopia and it's free on Itch if you are curious).

Everything was going fine until I started drawing a ton of these bears. I noticed the performance on AppGameKit was signifcantly worse than on GMS.

Here are the results : (Note that the sprite is 16x18 pixels )
AGK:
- 4000 Sprites rendered, 45 fps.
- 1 Sprite drawn 4000 times, 30 fps.
GMS 1.4
- 4000 Objects rendered, 200 fps.
- 4000 Sprite draws, 450 fps.

I did the same test but this time, using a bigger image of 400x200 pixels.
AGK:
- 1000 Sprites rendered, 3 fps.
- 1 Sprite drawn 1000 times, 17 fps.
GMS 1.4
- 1000 Objects rendered, 15 fps.
- 1000 Sprite draws, 15 fps.

As you can see, drawing 1000 big images in both engines gives more or less the same fps but when drawing 4000 smaller images, gms out-speeds agk by more than 10 times. I have a feeling the process of setting the parameters (vertex positions, shaders, etc..) fed to the gpu in AppGameKit is heavier than that of GMS. I might be wrong. I do not really understand whats happening under the hood.

To the AppGameKit community that reads this, please help me overcome this problem. I really want to use AppGameKit so badly but these fps is a such a letdown. Is there a way I could achieve higher fps when drawing 1000+ sprites?

...btw, I am using a pretty dated Acer laptop with Intel Pentium@2.0GHz (2 Cores) , Intel HD Graphics (yes, my laptop sucks but at least it gets the job done)

Back to top

Profile PM

hendron

8

Years of Service

User Offline

Joined: 20th Dec 2015

Location:

Posted: 30th Apr 2020 15:59

Link

It's hard to say without seeing any code. How are your sprites being created in AppGameKit?

Back to top

Profile PM

Grizzlius_Maximus

7

Years of Service

User Offline

Joined: 16th Oct 2017

Location:

Posted: 30th Apr 2020 16:54

Link

Here is the code for creating 1000 sprites at begin. Sprites get rendered using Sync()

+ Code Snippet

img_temp = agk::LoadImage("media/image.png");
for (int i = 0; i < 1000; i++) {
	spr_temp = agk::CreateSprite(img_temp);
}

The other test, 1 sprite drawn 1000 times, has this code at begin:

+ Code Snippet

img_temp = agk::LoadImage("media/image.png");
spr_temp = agk::CreateSprite(img_temp);

and this in the main loop:

+ Code Snippet

for (int i = 0; i < 1000; i++) {
	agk::DrawSprite(spr_temp);
}

I'm using Tier 2 if you haven't noticed.

Back to top

Profile PM

Paul Johnston

TGC Developer

22

Years of Service

User Offline

Joined: 16th Nov 2002

Location: United Kingdom

Posted: 30th Apr 2020 17:06 Edited at: 30th Apr 2020 17:07

Link

Using DrawSprite() in AppGameKit will create 1 draw call per sprite, which is likely the cause of the slow down. Using agk::Sync() will batch all the sprites into just a few draw calls, assuming they share images and shaders, which will be much faster. I guess GMS is taking the DrawSprite command as a signal that you want it to be drawn at some point in the future so it batches them up as it goes along, whereas AppGameKit takes DrawSprite as a signal to draw the sprite right now.

Back to top

Profile PM Email

Virtual Nomad

Moderator

18

Years of Service

User Offline

Joined: 14th Dec 2005

Location: SF Bay Area, USA

Posted: 30th Apr 2020 18:34 Edited at: 30th Apr 2020 18:39

Link

paul, in their Fiery Catacombs thread, Metamorpho was experiencing similar.

my response was similar to what you just offered.

meta came back with some test code, which i modified to:

SetErrorMode(2)
SetErrorMode(2)
SetWindowTitle( "TestSprite" )
SetWindowSize( 1024, 768, 0 )
SetWindowAllowResize( 1 ) // allow the user to resize the window
SetVirtualResolution( 1024, 768 ) // doesn't have to match the window
SetOrientationAllowed( 1, 1, 1, 1 ) // allow both portrait and landscape on mobile devices
SetSyncRate( 0, 1 ) 
SetScissor( 0,0,0,0 ) // use the maximum available screen space, no black borders
UseNewDefaultFonts( 1 ) // since version 2.0.22 we can use nicer default fonts

LoadImage(1, "crate.png")
ResizeImage(1,64,64)

////////////////////////////////////////////////////////   create 400 sprite
variant_1:

tin_x=200
tin_y=200

for x=1 to tin_x
    for y=1 to tin_y
		this = CreateSprite(1)
		SetSpritePosition(this,x*64,y*64) 
	next
next

ITs = 0
LastIt = 60
TotalTime1# = Timer()

repeat
 
	Print( "FPS: "+str(ScreenFPS()) + "   Sprites: "+str(GetManagedSpriteCount())+"  Drawcalls: "+str(GetManagedSpriteDrawCalls()) )
	Print(Its)
	INC ITs
	Sync()
    
	if ( GetRawKeyState(27) ) then exit
until ITs = LastIt

TotalTime1# = Timer() - TotalTime1#

DeleteAllSprites()

////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////  create 1 sprite
variant_2:

etno=CreateSprite(1)
SetSpritevisible(etno,1)

tin_x=200
tin_y=200

ITs = 0	
TotalTime2# = Timer()

Repeat
	for x=1 to tin_x
		for y=1 to tin_y
			SetSpritePosition(etno,x*64,y*64)
				drawsprite (etno) 
		next
	next
 
	Print( "FPS: "+str(ScreenFPS()) + "   Sprites: "+str(GetManagedSpriteCount())+"  Drawcalls: "+str(GetManagedSpriteDrawCalls()) )
	INC ITs
	Print(Its)
	Sync()
    
	if ( GetRawKeyState(27) ) then exit
until ITs = LastIt

TotalTime2# = Timer() - TotalTime2#

Avg1# = TotalTime1# / LastIt
Avg2# = TotalTime2# / LastIt

Do
	if ( GetRawKeyState(27) ) then exit
	
	print (STR(TotalTime1#) + " Avg: " + STR(Avg1#) )
	print (STR(TotalTime2#) + " Avg: " + STR(Avg2#) )
	print (Avg2#/Avg1#)
	Sync()
	
Loop

+ Code Snippet

SetErrorMode(2)
SetErrorMode(2)
SetWindowTitle( "TestSprite" )
SetWindowSize( 1024, 768, 0 )
SetWindowAllowResize( 1 ) // allow the user to resize the window
SetVirtualResolution( 1024, 768 ) // doesn't have to match the window
SetOrientationAllowed( 1, 1, 1, 1 ) // allow both portrait and landscape on mobile devices
SetSyncRate( 0, 1 ) 
SetScissor( 0,0,0,0 ) // use the maximum available screen space, no black borders
UseNewDefaultFonts( 1 ) // since version 2.0.22 we can use nicer default fonts

LoadImage(1, "crate.png")
ResizeImage(1,64,64)


////////////////////////////////////////////////////////   create 400 sprite
variant_1:

tin_x=200
tin_y=200

for x=1 to tin_x
    for y=1 to tin_y
		this = CreateSprite(1)
		SetSpritePosition(this,x*64,y*64) 
	next
next


ITs = 0
LastIt = 60
TotalTime1# = Timer()

repeat
 
	Print( "FPS: "+str(ScreenFPS()) + "   Sprites: "+str(GetManagedSpriteCount())+"  Drawcalls: "+str(GetManagedSpriteDrawCalls()) )
	Print(Its)
	INC ITs
	Sync()
    
	if ( GetRawKeyState(27) ) then exit
until ITs = LastIt

TotalTime1# = Timer() - TotalTime1#

DeleteAllSprites()

////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////  create 1 sprite
variant_2:

etno=CreateSprite(1)
SetSpritevisible(etno,1) 

tin_x=200
tin_y=200

ITs = 0	
TotalTime2# = Timer()

Repeat
	for x=1 to tin_x
		for y=1 to tin_y
			SetSpritePosition(etno,x*64,y*64)
				drawsprite (etno) 
		next
	next
 
	Print( "FPS: "+str(ScreenFPS()) + "   Sprites: "+str(GetManagedSpriteCount())+"  Drawcalls: "+str(GetManagedSpriteDrawCalls()) )
	INC ITs
	Print(Its)
	Sync()
    
	if ( GetRawKeyState(27) ) then exit
until ITs = LastIt

TotalTime2# = Timer() - TotalTime2#

Avg1# = TotalTime1# / LastIt
Avg2# = TotalTime2# / LastIt

Do
	if ( GetRawKeyState(27) ) then exit
	
	print (STR(TotalTime1#) + " Avg: " + STR(Avg1#) )
	print (STR(TotalTime2#) + " Avg: " + STR(Avg2#) )
	print (Avg2#/Avg1#)
	Sync()
	
Loop

the results changed my mind, leaving me to believe DrawSprite was (much/55-65%) quicker.

so, now i'm confused again.

of note? my system is dated, as well. and, has a laptop mobo with integrated graphics (didn't know it was a laptop in a tower when i bought it)... maybe this has something to do with it?

My Itch.io Home.

Back to top

Profile PM Website

Paul Johnston

TGC Developer

22

Years of Service

User Offline

Joined: 16th Nov 2002

Location: United Kingdom

Posted: 30th Apr 2020 23:58

Link

In that example most of the sprites are off screen, so the overhead of sorting and batching the sprites loses out to drawing them one at a time when most of them are rejected. Changing the positions so all the sprites are on screen reverses the results so DrawSprite is slower, but I guess that wouldn't be an accurate test for the game in that thread.

The batch routine in AppGameKit Classic wasn't very efficient so it got rewritten for Studio, which produces the same frame rate for both the batch and DrawSprite methods when most of the sprites are off screen. However it also revealed that when most of the sprites are on screen then DrawSprite absolutely kills the new renderer (both OpenGL and Vulkan).

So it seems to be that in Classic use batching if most of the sprites are on screen, and DrawSprite otherwise. But in Studio always use batching.

Back to top

Profile PM Email

Sorry your browser is not supported!

AppGameKit Classic Chat / Benchmarking AGK Sprite Draws