It's not only too many opinions, it's too many uninformed opinions.
Do a little research with the top independent test labs, especially in the gaming fields, who test CPU's on a regular basis. You will find that AMD is indeed the gaming platform of choice, even though Intel spends more advertising money with the mag's.
As was stated before, both are excellent processors, and it would take some pretty serious equipment and testing to see the difference in performance on any given chips. If you just want the Intel name, you will have to spend a little more.
Crazy Grandpa