Quote: "All of the Top 12 did one very important thing - they either bettered the original or did something significantly different with it to merit attention"
I'm sorry to have to mention this Rich, but if this was the main yardstick by which the winners were decided, here is what I have done to the original Pong.
1)I provided 'realistic' physics which takes into account not only where the ball hits the paddle but also the angle of incidence of the ball onto the paddle in order to provide for better gameplay, whereas pong had a monotonous 45 degree bounce angle.
2)I introduced an advanced 3D mode that has never been attempted before in any game.
3)I provided for a two mouse controller game which has never been attempted before.
4)I provided a natural language coach which I doubt has been inserted into a game before.
5)I have rigidly maintained the "retroness" factor. There are still 2 paddles moving in a linear fashion. If I did otherwise, unlike some of the other games, it wouldn't be "retro pong" anymore.
I think 1) qualifies as "bettering the original" and 2),3) and 4) qualify as "doing something SIGNIFICANTLY DIFFERENT"
Quote: "not a free box of s/w or something."
This is the 3rd compo I've entered hoping to win a copy of DBPro. I must say that although winning isn't everything it does help when you have the extra cash for a bottle of beer.