I agree that console gaming is simpler and you worry less about measures made to prevent piracy or stupid things game companies put on you, in contrast to Origin, I had to install uPlay after I bought Anno 2070 off of Steam, it just seemed utterly pointless and delayed me from playing the game.
Of course, where one has weaknesses it also has strengths, I can't wait until I build my gaming PC. With stability, you were pretty unfortunate Matt, however, I think it's the case with any product out there - we get customers complaining because their washing machine broke down within 2 years and their old one lasted 10 years, ours do too, but you can't guarantee each and every one will.
One plus side to desktop PC's having a problem is that a lot of the time you can fix it yourself with your PC being an exception Matt.

But console gamers...even PS3 gamers can run into hardware issues, one friend had his PS3 die and a colleague had his 360 RROD recently. I don't think you're going to escape the problem, regardless of what kind of product you buy.
I PC & Console game and love both. I prefer each for different reasons. If I thought one sucked, well, I wouldn't game on it. Granted, I don't play my 360 as much as I used to, but unfortunately most of the games out at the moment feel stagnant. The last year, other than SW:TOR & WoW, has pretty much been filled with nostalgia gaming.
Quote: " The MMO guild that Seppuku and I belong to constantly suffers when raiding and whatnot, because people had to screw around with visual settings on certain boss fights, or some other weird PC-centric issue"
I never had to do that...but then again I used to run the game at insanely low settings, but I am proud of that little GMA, it managed to pull through, just as well considering I was a healer.

I have tried it on my now-fixed gaming laptop, but the card is kinda under performing (though doing better than the GMA), it'll get slow downs after a while on some games (including SW:TOR).
However, I see your point. Sadly when your PC died and SW:TOR went downhill (funny how the two coincide, perhaps Bioware should have invested in your new PC to save the game), I think during raids it was the least of our worries as you're probably aware. For most of us the server stability was the final straw, due to server issues we even got wiped on Gharj and that's normally a walk in the park for us...