Quote: " The fact of the matter is God let her survive for a purpose. "
What about the other 6 million jews? I guess they were just useless then?
Quote: "If you believe in fate, think of it this way: God planned fate"
While I do belive in fate, I do not belive in it the same way you do (ie ALL events in time serve a greater purpose).
Maybe the 6 million other jewish people where not useless. On second, maybe thier deaths just contributed to a senerio of human oppression so that when this woman escapes the gas chambers she could inspire a movie.
This is the problem with God coming down to inteverne. Why would god pick and choose the people he wishes to save while letting so many others suffer, be tortured, and die. If god really wants to inspire us, why would he choose such a horrifc setting to place the story?
if God
is all powerful, all knowing, and Omni-benevolent, God will be able to create the universe to his liking, and everything goes according to his plan.
God could have planned the entire timeline of the universe already. If this is true, that means he planned entirley good events as well as all the bad events. This duality in god's attitude makes him seem to be an Amoral being (one whos actions are not intended for good or evil)instead of a Moral one.
------------------------
You can't just say "the guy this happened to isn't dead yet, so he's bound to serve some purpose". You can infer from this statement that Osama BIn laden must serve a purpose since he isn't dead yet (the americans should have captured of killed him already, but somehow he keeps evading them). Or what about the murders, rapist, theives that still exist?
----------------------
The truth is that these events may be amazing and cause people to think some super-natural being helped situations out, but in reality they are nothing more then chance encouters.
And the fact that this guys is still alive proves nothing about God intentions, or even the fact that god planned the events or intevened.
Amist the Blue Skies...