Quote: "If someone Muslim or not directly threatens to kill you, it's a criminal offense, why cant I get that across?"
I wish that were true.
Quote: "I think at this point some people have too much invested to hear or admit that an actual crime was committed. It kind of ruins the whole.... "for no reason" defense."
Thanks for that nonsense reply that adds nothing to the debate.
Quote: "Same as above. I am having a hard time understanding how some arrive at certainty after saying themselves there is nothing to go on in coming to that conclusion."
You're right, its' just a personal hunch that some of us have I guess. Some of us believe in the innocent-until-proven-guilty thing.
Quote: "But if somebody feels threatened, doesn't mean a threat was given."
Absolutely. And just because someone said something that hurt someone's feelings, doesn't mean they should be punished for it. Where I come from "hurting someone's feelings" isn't a crime.
Quote: "So you're basically saying people with completely innocent intentions are still committing crimes by jokingly making threats?"
It sounds a lot like that to me, although I'm hoping I'm mistaken.
I think you all have to remember here that this kid's life may have been ruined all because of a silly joke* that he didn't realise was so offensive to make. I can't make any guess as to what kind of person he is, but it's very possible that half a year in prison may scar him for life. Meanwhile, where's the evidence of a motive that the counter-terror organisations are doubtless researching? Perhaps it's inevitable given what's going on in the world right now, but it's really not fair. I guess if that's how it's got to be, then what I'm saying is "life isn't fair", but I'm not sure if that has to be the case.
* Note that I'm not really sure I think it was a 'joke' in the sense of humour, but it seems he was angry at the person he was talking to and wanted to shock them by saying something like that. I agree with others that say it's completely unacceptable to say things like that, and he certainly should be made aware (punished, if need be), but not to the extent that might damage his psyche. It's even possible he's now been desensitized to violence, and may be more likely to do it in the future.
EDIT
Quote: "Maybe a more fitting punishment would be to sit them down with some folks who lost family and friends and explain to them what was so funny about your joke. (This goes for you too Wolf)"
If it were possible, that would be a great idea. Every person should know just how much of an emotional impact these silly comments can make on people (not to mention the security implications of impersonating a would-be terrorist), and while I'm not sure people should be punished by the law for doing it, I think they should certainly be made to understand what they did was wrong, and why.
"Sideboobs are awesome. Getting punched in the face is not." - Jerico2Day on violence and nudity